I need some more space, so will remove the two old drives and setup another raid. Usb3 i have the thunderbay mini tb2 with raid 5 and swap ssd or hard drives. It is just whether you abstract it to a daughter card or let the main os do it. Software raid on windows tends to have a reputation for working well enough for redundancy, but not working well performancewise, but from my research it looks like it is usually raid 5 in software with windows that you really take a hit. Jan 29, 2016 owc is both a reseller and developer, supporting all things mac for more than 25 years and larry is here to explain the difference between a software raid and a hardware raid, and how to. If you need more disk ports you can always get an hba host bus adapter card. What is the performance implication of hardware vs. It has windows, linux, and mac drivers all available from their website. With cheaper hardware raid you can also lose data if theres a power outage.
A redundant array of inexpensive disks raid allows high levels of storage reliability. Im only using the raid card for personal use from what i. Does os xs disk utility create hardware raid or software. In a hardware raid setup, the drives connect to a raid controller card. External enclosure raid vs software raid spiceworks. Two disks, sata 3, hardware raid 0 hardware raid 0. With software raid your data can be split across different enclosures for complete redundancy one enclosure can completely stop working and your data is still ok.
For software raid i used the linux kernel software raid functionality of a system running 64bit fedora 9. The latest mac and pc hardware and software deliver a lot of capability, including the option of building a software raid. Aug 25, 2010 software raid means that the raid is handled by the general purpose os and hardware raid means that the raid is handled by a special purpose satasas controller card that runs its own os, cpu, memory, etc. Selfbuilt nas wfreenas and a hardware raid controller.
Of course, i am interested in having an internal raid setup, so external ports are not needed but appreciated in case a. If one drive goes down on a mirrored raid array, then the data is immediately still accessible. One thing that more expensive raid cards have is large buffers. There is definitively and advantage with using hardware raid which is the speed.
With removable drives, this ultrafast, highcapacity storage solution is designed for the most demanding applications while easily supporting multistream hd, 2k, 4k and hdr. Hardware raid will cost more, but it will also be free of software raid s. Sas raid controller for mac pro 5,1 macrumors forums. All a hardware raid card is is a small computer inside the main computer with a small cpu, some ram and a satasas controller running software raid. A raid can be deployed using both software and hardware. Hardware raid costs more, but will be free of software raid. What is a raid controller and what are the advantages of it. In case youre wondering, a software raid is one where the mac manages the raid. A raid with 3 drives in it all else being equal, will perform near identically in maximum throughput in a software raid0 as in a hardware raid0 and the software raid will be a tad faster responding lower latency since the hardware raid has more steps to go through to access the drives. Ive been told that for a powerful workstation like the mac pro with plenty of cores and ram, software raid is as good, or even better, than hardware raid certainly for raid 0. Feb 28, 2018 raid redundant array of independent disks is one of the popular data storage virtualization technology. Akitios data storage products make use of both hardware and software raid, depending the model. Hardware raid is dependant on the card and os driver. With hardware raid, if the enclosure fails, you can lose all your data.
The mac pro on the other hand completely collapsed after ripping out the raid card and setting up the 4 drives as raid 0 under disk utility. Windows software raid vs hardware raid 10 posts arlesterc. Hence, plugging the software raided drives into the hardware controller will likely result in unreadable drives. While you might think the computer you are using is the most important part of your everyday and professional workflows, there is. We list the pros and cons of hardware vs software raid to help you. Real hardware raid is going to be really expensive. Mar 11, 2011 well since osx doesnt support software raid past 01 your only option is a hardware raid. Jun, 2016 comparing hardware raid vs software raid setups deals with how the storage drives in a raid array connect to the motherboard in a server or pc, and the management of those drives. The adaptec hardware raid card, the aaaudma, performed 5% faster than the pure ide drive. In a hardware raid setup, the drives connect to a raid controller card inserted in a fast pciexpress pcie slot in a motherboard. It is still software but running on a dedicated controller. There are several ways to setup the arrayonboard bios, windows and mac desktop utility, and also via the internal card web server, either from a local browser or over the network. It is used to improve disk io performance and reliability of your server or workstation.
Side by side, intel % change vs software raid 0 intel performance increase over microsoft. As far as fault tolerance goes, ill respectfully disagree. I will tell you two reasons why i wont use software raid anymore. Hardware raid is dedicated processing system, using controllers or raid cards to manage the raid configuration independently from the operating system. Even if you dont go with one of the fancier software controllers like zfs or btrfs id still recommend going with a software raid. Trying to find the best raid option with what i got, so i decided to test the speed difference between onboard raid and software raid in windows. Linuxbased software raid is regarded as mature and very usable. This table summarizes the key differences between hardware and software raids.
There is maczfs and zevo which should come out next month but i doubt youll be able to get the speeds you can get with a dedicated hardware raid card. A replacement raid card, especially after a few years can be impossible. Comparing hardware raid vs software raid setups deals with how the storage drives in a raid array connect to the motherboard in a server or pc, and the management of those drives. The dedicated hardware controller has two different architectures. Finally, the promise supertrak100 hardware raid card outperformed the ide drive by 3%. Favoring hardware raid over software raid comes from a time when hardware was just not powerful enough to handle software raid processing, along with all the other tasks that it was being used for. The raid can be implemented either using a special controller hardware raid, or by an operating system driver software raid. Prior to this i, too, looked at hardware or software raid and decided that the new software, softraid, in combination with other improved hardware was fine. The end result is that you need to physically move data from the old software raid to the new hardware raid system.
To put those sidebyside, heres the difference you can expect when comparing hardware raid 0 to software raid 0. I would generally agree with a preference for hardware vs. Hardware raid cards must include memory for cache as well as extra controls to power. In a hardware raid setup, the drives connect to a special raid controller inserted in a fast pciexpress pcie slot in a motherboard. Solved hardware raid vs software lsi cards spiceworks. Whether software raid vs hardware raid is the one for you depends on what you need to do and how much you want to pay. Jul 15, 2012 there is definitively and advantage with using hardware raid which is the speed. I have been using raid on macs and pcs since 1999, and i have done it in software and 78 different kinds cards on various oses. Apr 16, 2020 implementing raid needs to use either hardware raid special controller or software raid an operating system driver. See installing mac os x server on a hardware raid volume above for an overview of software installation and chapter 5. Hardware vs software raid controllers hardware based. Onboard raid vs windows 10 raid speed test experiment.
Apple mac os x, hp hpux, ibm aix, linux, microsoft windows ab windows nt. Plus, software raid permits users to reconfigure your arrays without being restricted by the hardware raid controller. Softwareraid gegen hardwareraid im benchmarkvergleich. The terms hardware raid and software raid are very misleading as all raid controllers do raid using software. The software raid they use is generally inferior to the software raid that you can get from your os, natively. You must configure the card and drive modules to use its raid features. Pros and cons choosing between software raid and hardware raid depends on what you need to do and cost.
But to appease the powers that be, i have explained the two below hardware raid is when you have a dedicated controller to do the work for you. What is the difference between a software and hardware raid. What are the pros and cons of using the hardware raid card, vs the software raid. Back then, the solution was to use a hardware raid card with a builtin processor that handled the raid calculations offline. The card i purchased on ebay was the areca arc1880ixl12. The graid with thunderbolt 3 is a highperformance, dual enterpriseclass 7200rpm hard drive storage system featuring thunderbolt 3, usbcsupports usb 3. Create a disk set using disk utility on mac apple support. You can also create a set that concatenates smaller disks to act as one larger disk. You can easily move disks from a failed enclosure to a new one, and all your data is preserved. To be safe, check with the manufacturer of your raid to see if any updates are needed. Imho, im a big fan of kernel developers non directly related to zfs, so i really prefere mdadm to hardware raid. The problem is i cant get boot campwindows to work on a second partition on any of the drives. Even with an hardware raid controller inside an arbitrary device, disk utility cant createhandle hardware raids because it doesnt contain the necessary drivers to do so.
Theres hardware raid and then theres hardware raid. A hardware raid is created by a builtin raid controller and is independent of the computer and the operating system. This is critical if you plan to access your raid system from a mac and a windows. There is not reason to go for hardware raid just for two drives in raid 1. I dont know if the software raid uses ram as a buffer in the same way id assume it does. My experience with hardware and fake hardware raid is that as long as you stay with the same vendor, the raid metadata will be recognized ive seen this when moving drives between various hp, areca and lsi hardware raid controllers, and with intel, amd and even via hostraid i was pretty surprised when i connected a 250gb hard drive from some old amd desktop box to a hp g1 microserver, and. I do manipulate large images files 1 gb and in order to make the whole process faster i know that i need really fast hard drive. Raid 5 with hot spare disks, raid 1 or 10 should be more tolerant. Oct 30, 2015 now, lets see how windows raid 0 stacks up to actual hardware raid. Software vs hardware raid performance and cache usage server. Which means the best bet is always a hardware raid card. But a great many people are unclear about their differences.
But the real question is whether you should use a hardware raid solution or a software raid solution. The mac pro raid card offers improved storage performance and data protection to your mac pro system up to 553mbs of sequential read performance in raid 0. In time i went thru 2 raid cards on the original 2008 mac pro but the second one killed the machine all together. What is the difference between hardware and software raid. Yes it can happen, but it is far more rare than often claimed. To compare software raid vs hardware raid, its also necessary to figure out what software raid is. A hardware raid is created by a builtin raid controller and is independent of the. When your storage drives are directly connected to the servers motherboard without a raid controller, the raid configuration will be managed by the utility software in the operating system. Raid controller card is an expansion card inserted into a pcie or pcix motherboard slot. Lets start the hardware vs software raid battle with the hardware side.
The problem with this is not only does a software raid use your computers processing power, but if your operating system crashes, the software raid goes with it. Jul 07, 2009 a redundant array of inexpensive disks raid allows high levels of storage reliability. Hardware raid vs os raid solutions experts exchange. So, the following part will discuss the hardware vs software raid to help you make a decision. Using the hardware raid pci card instructions for using the software provided with the hardware raid pci card.
Typically however, a hardware raid is faster because the processing for the parity bits and all that jazz is done on its own processor and not virtualized on to your main processor. That configuration is a defense against a hardware failure, not a software failure or user mishap. Jul 22, 2017 hardware raid in contrast to software raid, hardware raid involves the raid task being executed by the processor of a dedicated card or raid controller. Learn more about software and hardware raid volumes akitio. Apple raid configuration vs hardware raid super user. At this point do people prefer hardware raid or software. If you created a raid using disk utility in any version of the mac os prior to 10.
Everything else being equal, both software and hardware raid can be good. Meaning until the manufacturer open sources their tech internals, you cannot use open source software raid on a setup like that. Install windows on mac pro with software raid present. Software raid, such as softraid, can provide incredibly fast read and write speeds. Software raid versus hardware raid macrumors forums. It worked fine for a short while, then died hard with 3 unix screens of death and then it wouldnt boot. While you might think the computer you are using is the most important part of your everyday and professional workflows, there is something even more important. In addition, you are able to run raid 5 and 6 arrays which you cannot with softraid in os x.
Afaik the only apple tool for hardware raids is the raid admin or raid utility accompanying the mac pro raid card and xserve raid card. This works the same for larger servers as well as desktop computers. Configuring the hardware raid card erases mac os x server on the. Some raid cards will hide the whole array from the os but the driver will still know that it is raid. The 2009 version of the mac pro raid card is compatible with all mac pro models from 2009 through 2012. It will always be supported by linux kernels so no headaches. One of the first questions we felt needed to be answered was what exactly hardware raid cards do. Can mac pro do software raid 0 for the systems disk. Software raid virtually belongs to operating system. I have just installed a mac pro raid card in my 07 mac pro and the battery comes out as faulted and wont really charge.
Does os xs disk utility create hardware raid or software raid. Windows software raid vs hardware raid ars technica. Because data is processed on the card, hardware raid solutions are much more complex than software raid cards. From what i have heard as well i could set up caching using a ssd in a software raid a lot easier than a hardware raid, but the hardware raid has a built int bbu and 512mb of cache. A hardware raid is a raid array that includes a separate computer that manages the raid. Jun 26, 2019 depending on the raid controller and the amount of drives, different raid modes can be used.
Software raid means that the raid is handled by the general purpose os and hardware raid means that the raid is handled by a special purpose satasas controller card that runs its own os, cpu, memory, etc. Also if you have a decent raid implementation you will only lose data in a single stripe or file, not everything. Ive got 4 hard drives in my mac pro that are each used for a variety of software raid arrays for mac os. Hardware raid is dedicated processing system, using controllers or raid cards to manage the raid configuration independently from the. So upgrades and handling failures becomes trivial since the software controller can come with you to the new hardware.
33 1167 318 1268 868 6 721 754 1088 1346 1204 1243 518 1481 1449 520 1063 75 511 1492 1674 548 247 980 1108 692 236 468 1167 674 140 220 611